Mc. Newman et al., Applying species-sensitivity distributions in ecological risk assessment: Assumptions of distribution type and sufficient numbers of species, ENV TOX CH, 19(2), 2000, pp. 508-515
Species-sensitivity distribution methods assemble single-species toxicity d
ata to predict hazardous concentrations (HCps) affecting a certain percenta
ge (p) of species in a community. The fit of the lognormal model and requir
ed number of individual species values were evaluated with 30 published dat
a sets. The increasingly common assumption that a lognormal model best fits
these data was not supported. Fifteen data sets failed a formal test of co
nformity to a lognormal distribution; other distributions often provided be
tter fit to the data than the lognormal distribution. An alternate bootstra
p method provided accurate estimates of HCp without the assumption of a spe
cific distribution. Approximate sample sizes producing HC5 estimates with m
inimal variance ranged from 15 to 55, and had a median of 30 species-sensit
ivity values. These sample sizes are higher than those suggested in recent
regulatory documents. A bootstrap method is recommended that predicts with
95% confidence the concentration affecting 5% or fewer species.