M. Neises et Hj. Strottmatter, DOES RECONSTRUCTIVE BREAST SURGERY AND BREAST-CONSERVING THERAPY IMPROVE THE QUALITY-OF-LIFE, Onkologie, 20(2), 1997, pp. 118-121
Diseases and malfunctions of the sexual organs are always linked to a
woman's sense of identity and, in most cases, will impair it. This ent
ails the question of whether and how the disease or the removal of a s
exual organ affects the gender identity and female body image, and the
patient's sexuality as well. When developing operative procedures dri
ven by functional/cosmetic considera tions, it was assumed that a less
er extent of visible operative mutilation would also involve a lesser
psyche-social burden. Numerous studies have produced differentiated co
nclusions with the one major difference between the operation procedur
es located in the area of body image and femininity. Women operated on
with breast retention have a significantly better body image with mor
e positive bodily/sexual self-esteem that do women following a mastect
omy. When it comes to coping with the illness most studies find no dif
ferences dependent on the type of operation involved. The argument mos
t frequently adducted for mastectomy is the allegedly lower fear of re
cidivation experienced by mastectomy amputees. Significantly more appr
ehension is reported among women operated on with breast retention. Th
ese women were afraid of having received the 'wrong' operation. Anothe
r reported sourer of apprehension is the uncertainty as to whether the
surgeon has in fact removed the entire tumor. Mastectomy amputees, co
nversely, are more certain that the cancer has been cured. However, ma
stectomy amputees also tended to report more fear of the future and mo
re frequent thoughts about their illness Studies which examined the pr
e-operative situation and counseling as interaction variables found th
at a free option to decide on the type of operation, or a fostering of
autonomous decision making, reduces subsequent psychiatric morbidity.
Breast amputation should not be talked down to a purely cosmetic prob
lem. Gynecological operations of this kind are also major intervention
s in the life-story of the women involved. Breast retention can allevi
ate difficulties in certain areas and lead to a better quality of life
subsuming physical, psychological and social well-being.