Usually a frequency-stabilized standing wave resonator-oscillator incorpora
ting a resonator as a frequency discriminator requires a circulator to sepa
rate the injected and reflected wave. A ferrite circulator is a noisy devic
e and can limit the phase noise or frequency stability. Moreover, we show t
hat the noise in a circulator varies, and detailed low noise measurements a
re necessary to choose an appropriate quiet circulator. Thus, by realizing
a configuration that does not require a circulator, an improvement in perfo
rmance and reliability can be obtained. A solution to this problem is to de
sign a high-Q whispering gallery traveling wave (WGTW) resonator. This devi
ce naturally separates the injected and reflected wave in the same way as a
ring cavity at optical frequencies, without degrading the frequency discri
mination. Q-factor measurements of a WGTW sapphire resonator are presented,
along with a derivation of critical parameters to maximize the frequency d
iscrimination. New measurements of noise in ferrite circulators and isolato
rs have also been made, which is followed with a discussion on oscillator d
esign.