Considerable research shows that withdrawal severity is inconsistently rela
ted to smoking cessation outcomes. This result from measurement problems or
failure to scrutinize important dimensions of the withdrawal experience. T
wo recent studies demonstrated that withdrawal elevation and, variations in
the time course of withdrawal. were related to relapse in smokers treated
with the nicotine patch (T. M. Piasecki, M. C. Fiore, & T.B. Baker, 1998).
This article reports a conceptual replication and extension of those findin
gs in unaided quitters, Evidence for temporal heterogeneity was found acros
s different types of withdrawal symptoms. Patterns or slopes of affect and
urge reports over time predicted smoking status at follow-up, as did mean e
levation in withdrawal symptoms. These results suggest that affect and urge
withdrawal symptoms make independent contributions to relapse and that rel
apse is related to both symptom severity and trajectory.