B. Jonasson et al., Among fatal poisonings dextropropoxyphene predominates in younger people, antidepressants in the middle aged and sedatives in the elderly, J FOREN SCI, 45(1), 2000, pp. 7-10
To compare the characteristics of dextropropoxyphene (DXP) poisoning victim
s with those of victims of poisonings by antidepressants and sedatives, we
examined all fatal poisonings due to DXP, antidepressants or sedatives amon
g autopsies performed at one department of forensic medicine in Sweden duri
ng the six-year period from 1992 to 1997.
In 202 cases, death was classified as fatal poisonings by DXP, antidepressa
nts or sedatives. DXP caused death in 78 cases (39%), antidepressants in 49
(24%), and sedatives in 75 (37%). DXP as a single preparation was predomin
ant in causing death. The second compound, flunitrazepam, caused death in 3
0 cases (15%).
The victims of poisonings by DXP, antidepressants, or sedatives shared a si
milar history of alcohol/drug abuse, depression and somatic illness. They w
ere mostly living alone at the time of death (>60%), the majority died at h
ome (81%), and suicide was the most frequent manner of death (73%).
Age seemed to be an important characteristic regarding the choice of drug.
Younger people predominantly died of DXP (mean age 43 years, 95% confidence
interval, CI 39-47), and elderly people of sedatives (mean age 59 years, C
I 55-63). Antidepressants were found mainly in middle-aged victims (mean ag
e 51 years, CI 48-54).
The predominance of sedatives among the elderly might be explained by a ver
y high prescription rate of such drugs in older age groups, but prescriptio
n rate could not explain the DXP predominance among younger people. We hypo
thesize that younger people are more prone to abuse therapeutic drugs for e
uphoric reasons than elderly people, and that because of its high toxicity,
DXP leads to accidental deaths more often than sedatives.