Receptor binding to human poliovirus type 1 (PV1/M) and the major group of
human rhinoviruses (HRV) was studied comparatively to uncover the evolution
of receptor recognition in picornaviruses. Surface plasmon resonance showe
d receptor binding to PV1/M with faster association and dissociation rates
than to HRV3 and HRV16, two serotypes that have similar binding kinetics. T
he faster rate for receptor association to PV1/M suggested a relatively mor
e accessible binding site. Thermodynamics for receptor binding to the virus
es and assays for receptor-mediated virus uncoating showed a more disruptiv
e receptor interaction with PV1/M than with HRV3 or HRV16. Cryoelectron mic
roscopy and image reconstruction of receptor-PV1/M complexes revealed recep
tor binding to the 'wall' of surface protrusions surrounding the 'canyon',
a depressive surface in the capsid where the rhinovirus receptor binds. The
se data reveal more exposed receptor-binding sites in poliovirus than rhino
viruses, which are less protected from immune surveillance but more suited
for receptor-mediated virus uncoating and entry at the cell surface.