N. Baurin et al., 3D-QSAR CoMFA study on imidazolinergic I-2 ligands: A significant model through a combined exploration of structural diversity and methodology, J MED CHEM, 43(6), 2000, pp. 1109-1122
Displaying an unprecedented structural diversity, 119 I-2 ligands, and thei
r pK(i) values, were collected and submitted to a comparative molecular fie
lds analysis (CoMFA) study. They were discerned into three structural subse
ts (A, B, C), to explore the I-2 3D-QSARs from finite structural systems (A
, B, C) to more complex ones (AB, AC, BC, ABC). In addition, various key st
eps of the CoMFA methology were explored. The applied method used two pharm
acophore templates and seven molecular field combinations (electrostatic, l
ipophilic, steric), as well as eight alignment methods (two point-by-point
and six similarity-based variations). That way, 644 CoMFA models were obtai
ned and further selected according to their predictive ability through two
filters. The first filter was mainly based on the q(2), which internally ev
aluates the predictive ability from the training set. For the second filter
, the predictive ability was externally evaluated through the prediction of
test sets. Finally, one model was extracted from the whole data as the bes
t. Indeed, it combines three features of upmost importance for the further
design of ligands endowed with high It affinity: structural diversity (n =
73), robustness (N = 9, r(2) = 0.96, s = 0.28, F = 148), and a great fully
assessed predictive ability (q(2) = 0.50, r(2) (test set) = 0.81, n(test se
t) = 46). On the basis of structural data and CoMFA isocontours, some eleme
nts of the It tridimensional pharmacophore are also suggested.