This article investigates whether the contractual exclusion of third-party
extended warranties should be legally permissible, using a model incorporat
ing consumer heterogeneity. The welfare effects of competition in the marke
t for extended warranties are shown to depend on the degree of competition
in the product market. In contrast to the approach typically adopted by the
courts, the article argues that manufacturers should not generally be perm
itted to practice requirements contracting in extended warranties, even whe
n the product market is competitive.