Ms. Markell et al., UNEMPLOYMENT IN INNER-CITY RENAL-TRANSPLANT RECIPIENTS - PREDICTIVE AND SOCIODEMOGRAPHIC FACTORS, American journal of kidney diseases, 29(6), 1997, pp. 881-887
Studies of dialysis patients report unemployment rates of 60% to 75%;
however, it is generally believed that following transplantation, impr
ovement in well-being and removal of time constraints imposed by the d
ialytic regimen afford improvement in employment status. We studied 58
stable renal transplant recipients attending an outpatient transplant
clinic by questionnaire, administered anonymously. Only 25 (43%) of t
he patients were currently employed. Employed and unemployed patients
did not differ when compared for age, gender, race, cause of renal dis
ease, type of transplant or prior dialysis, time on dialysis or time s
ince transplantation, years of education, or prestige score or classif
ication (''blue collar'' v ''white collar'') of prior job. In the empl
oyed group, 24 (96%) patients had worked before developing kidney dise
ase compared with 23 (70%) patients in the unemployed group (P < 0.05)
. While on dialysis, 19 (79%) of the employed patients continued worki
ng compared with 10 (30%) of the unemployed patients (P < 0.005), Majo
r reasons for discontinuing work after starting dialysis for both grou
ps were subjective illness (feeling too sick, 51%), followed by interf
erence of the dialysis regimen with time necessary for work (32%). Onl
y 15% of the previously employed patients did not work after transplan
tation because of feeling too sick. By multiple logistic regression, t
he strongest predictors of employment posttransplant were being more t
han 1 year posttransplant (odds ratio, 2.36; 95% confidence interval,
1.01 to 5.5) and having been employed before transplantation (odds rat
io, 3.79; 95% confidence interval, 1.60 to 9.02). Over half of the une
mployed patients (20 [61%]) expressed interest in job training, Eighty
percent to 90% of patients in both groups were insured by Medicare, w
ith the second greatest number insured by Medicaid. Of the 15 unemploy
ed patients insured by Medicaid, 67% reported that their decision not
to work was related to fear of losing Medicaid benefits because they c
ould not afford medications without it, Despite no difference in actua
l type of insurance carried, 17 (51%) of the unemployed patients belie
ved their health insurance coverage was inadequate compared with four
(12%) of the employed patients (P = 0.005, chi-squared test), Unemploy
ment remains a significant problem for our population of inner-city re
nal transplant recipients. Attention to job retention or retraining du
ring the early renal disease and dialysis therapy period may promote b
etter rehabilitation following transplantation. However, for this popu
lation, with limited employment opportunities, removal of disincentive
s to work, including loss of insurance and inability to pay for medica
tions, will be necessary before we can provide optimal rehabilitation
for renal transplant recipients from all social strata. (C) 1997 by th
e National Kidney Foundation, Inc.