Using an innovative telephone survey design, this study investigates the po
ssibility that 'reluctant' respondents may give significantly different wil
lingness to pay (WTP) responses in contingent valuation surveys. Two differ
ent measures of respondent reluctance are evaluated (interviewer assessed a
nd respondent assessed). Evidence of a reluctant respondent effect is prese
nt in an open-ended elicitation format but not in a dichotomous choice elic
itation format. Implications for survey design and WTP modelling are discus
sed.