The aim of this paper is to examine up to what extent the so-called generic
non-linear dynamic (GNLD) load models can replace a more detailed represen
tation of aggregate load, including induction motors, thermostatically cont
rolled and static loads, in long-term voltage stability simulations. In the
first part of the paper the main characteristics of the GNLD models are co
mpared with those of more detailed models considered as 'reference'. It is
concluded that the long-term instability phenomena are closely reproduced,
in most cases, by using the GNLD model. The accuracy of the GNLD reproducti
on depends on the load characteristics, the type of phenomena that have to
be reproduced and the position of the load in the network. Short-term insta
bility phenomena solely due to induction motor dynamics might not be reprod
uced with adequate accuracy by GNLD models that are characterised by an inh
erent de-coupling of active and reactive power. Further, the possibility of
including on load tap changer transformer into GNLD models is investigated
and accomplished. These considerations are illustrated by adopting as case
study a network often used in the literature. (C) 2000 Published by Elsevi
er Science Ltd. All rights reserved.