R. Tamblyn et al., Using medical services claims to assess injuries in the elderly: sensitivity of diagnostic and procedure codes for injury ascertainment, J CLIN EPID, 53(2), 2000, pp. 183-194
Citations number
36
Categorie Soggetti
Envirnomentale Medicine & Public Health","Medical Research General Topics
The sensitivity of using physician claims data for injury ascertainment was
examined in a cohort of 1,181 elderly who were treated in the emergency de
partment of one of 10 hospitals for injuries in 1993-1994. The clinical rec
ord of the type and date of injury was compared with diagnostic and procedu
re codes in the Quebec health insurance agency records of physician billing
claims for the same patients. The proportion of patients correctly classif
ied by claims data was determined for the exact date of injury and for a ti
me window around the date of injury. The most common injuries were fracture
s (55.4%) and lacerations (19.3%), and 78.9% of injuries were fall related.
Overall, the combination of treatment procedure codes and diagnostic codes
provided the most sensitive measure of injury occurrence; a sensitivity of
67.3% for the exact date and 81.3% for an expanded data window (95.6% of i
njuries were within - 1 day to + 3 days of the injury date). Sensitivity va
ried by injury type form a low of 14% for abrasions to a high of 97.2% for
hip fractures. The combination of diagnostic and procedure codes in physici
an claims is a sensitive indicator of some common injuries that would not b
e documented in hospitalization databases. (C) 2000 Elsevier Science Inc. A
ll rights reserved.