Jt. Guthrie et al., Contributions of instructional practices to reading achievement in a statewide improvement program, J EDUC RES, 93(4), 2000, pp. 211-225
The amount and direction of school change in reading achievement on a state
wide, high-stakes performance assessment were identified, School change in
reading achievement with instructional practices reported by teachers in pr
imary and intermediate grades in 33 schools was predicted. Meta-analyses of
the effects of instructional practices in reading on achievement in 6 area
s-including reading, writing, language use, mathematics, science, and socia
l studies-were conducted. In Grade 5, achievement in reading, science, math
ematics, and writing increased significantly. Practices of integrated instr
uction and use of abundant texts and resources were associated positively w
ith change in achievement. Basal emphasis and comprehension instruction wer
e associated negatively with achievement change. In Grade 3, few effects we
re observed. Findings are interpreted in light of existing models of integr
ated instruction and the roles of teacher knowledge in achievement and lear
ning.