OBJECTIVE: TO report a case of antiretroviral therapy failure caused by an
interaction between carbamazepine and indinavir.
CASE SUMMARY: A 48-year-old HIV-positive white man was treated with antiret
roviral triple therapy, consisting of indinavir, zidovudine, and lamivudine
. His HIV-RNA (viral load) became undetectable (<400 copies/mL) less than t
wo months after this therapy was started; this was confirmed one month late
r. Shortly after the start of antiretroviral therapy, the patient developed
herpes tester, which was treated with famciclovir. Tramadol was initially
prescribed for postherpetic neuralgia; however, this was substituted with c
arbamazepine due to insufficient analgesic effect. Indinavir plasma concent
rations decreased substantially during carbamazepine therapy. Carbamazepine
was stopped after 2.5 months and, two weeks later, the HIV-RNA was detecta
ble (6 x 10(3) copies/mL). Resistance for lamivudine was observed in that b
lood sample; resistance for zidovudine might have been present, and resista
nce to indinavir was not detected. A few months later, a further increase o
f the HIV-RNA occurred (300 x 10(3) copies/mL), after which the therapy was
switched to a new antiretroviral regimen containing nevirapine, didanosine
, and stavudine.
DISCUSSION: Physicians may prescribe carbamazepine for HIV-infected patient
s to treat seizures or postherpetic neuralgia, which are complications of o
pportunistic infections such as herpes tester or toxoplasmosis. Carbamazepi
ne is a potent enzyme inducer, predominantly of the CYP3A enzyme system, wh
ile HIV-protease inhibitors such as indinavir are substrates for and inhibi
tors of CYP3A. Therefore, an interaction between these drugs could be expec
ted. A low dose of carbamazepine (200 mg/d) and the usual dose of indinavir
(800 mg q8h) in our patient resulted in carbamazepine concentrations withi
n the therapeutic range for epilepsy treatment; indinavir concentrations dr
opped substantially. The virologic, resistance, and plasma drug concentrati
on data, as well as the chronology of events, are highly indicative of anti
retroviral treatment failure due to the interaction between carbamazepine a
nd indinavir.
CONCLUSIONS: Concomitant use of carbamazepine and indinavir may cause failu
re of antiretroviral therapy due to insufficient indinavir plasma concentra
tions. Drugs other than carbamazepine should be considered to prevent this
interaction. Amitriptyline or gabapentin are alternatives for postherpetic
neuralgia; valproic acid or lamotrigine are alternatives for seizures. When
alternate drug therapy is not possible, dosage adjustments, therapeutic dr
ug monitoring, and careful clinical observation may help reduce adverse cli
nical consequences.