Em. Miller, Homosexuality, birth order, and evolution: Toward an equilibrium reproductive economics of homosexuality, ARCH SEX BE, 29(1), 2000, pp. 1-34
The survival of a human predisposition for homosexuality can be explained b
y sexual orientation being a polygenetic trait that is influenced by a numb
er of genes. During development these shift male brain development in the f
emale direction. Inheritance of several such alleles produces homosexuality
. Single alleles make for greater sensitivity, empathy, tendermindedness, a
nd kindness. These traits make heterosexual carriers of the genes better fa
thers and more attractive mates. There is a balanced polymorphism in which
the feminizing effect of these alleles in heterosexuals offsets the adverse
effects (on reproductive success) of these alleles' contribution to homose
xuality. A similar effect probably occurs for genes that can produce lesbia
nism in females. The whole system survives because it serves to provide a h
igh degree of variability among the personalities of offspring, providing t
he genotype with diversification and reducing competition among offspring f
or the same niches. An allele with a large effect can survive in these circ
umstances in males, but it is less likely to survive in females. The birth
order effect on homosexuality is probably a by-product of a biological mech
anism that shifts personalities more in the feminine direction in the later
born sons, reducing the probability of these sons engaging in unproductive
competition with each other.