Fiat and bona fide boundaries

Citation
B. Smith et Ac. Varzi, Fiat and bona fide boundaries, PHILOS PHEN, 60(2), 2000, pp. 401-420
Citations number
33
Categorie Soggetti
Philosiphy
Journal title
PHILOSOPHY AND PHENOMENOLOGICAL RESEARCH
ISSN journal
00318205 → ACNP
Volume
60
Issue
2
Year of publication
2000
Pages
401 - 420
Database
ISI
SICI code
0031-8205(200003)60:2<401:FABFB>2.0.ZU;2-Z
Abstract
There is a basic distinction, in the realm of spatial boundaries, between b ona fide boundaries on the one hand, and fiat boundaries on the other. The former are just the physical boundaries of old. the latter are exemplified especially by boundaries induced through human demarcation, for example, in the geographic domain. The classical metaphysical problems connected with the notions of adjacency, contact, separation, and division can be resolved in an intuitive way by recognizing this two-sorted ontology of boundaries. Bona fide boundaries yield a notion of contact that is effectively modelle d by classical topology; the analogue of contact involving fiat boundaries calls, however, for a different account, based on the intuition that fiat b oundaries do not support the open/closed distinction on which classical top ology is based. In the presence of this two-sorted ontology it then transpi res that mereotopology-typology erected on a mereological basis-is more tha n a trivial formal variant of classical point-st topology.