Synthetic MgGa2O4-Mg2GeO4 spinel solid solution and beta-Mg3Ga2GeO8: chemistry, crystal structures, cation ordering, and comparison to Mg2GeO4 olivine

Structural parameters and cation ordering are determined for four compositi ons in the synthetic MgGa2O4-Mg2GeO4 spinel solid solution (0, 8, 15 and 23 mol% Mg2GeO4; 1400 degrees C, 1 bar) and for spinelloid beta-Mg3Ga2GeO8 (1 350 degrees C, 1 bar), by Rietveld refinement of room-temperature neutron d iffraction data. Sample chemistry is determined by XRF and EPMA. Addition o f Mg2GeO4 causes the cation distribution of the MgGa2O4 component to change from a disordered inverse distribution in end member MgGa2O4, [(4)]Ga = x = 0.88(3), through the random distribution, toward a normal cation distribu tion, x = 0.37(3), at 23 mol% Mg2GeO4. An increase in a(o) with increasing Mg2GeO4 component is correlated with an increase in the amount of Mg on the tetrahedral site. through substitution of 2Ga(3+) reversible arrow Mg2+ Ge4+. The spinel exhibits high configurational entropy, reaching 20.2 J mol (four oxygen basis) near the compositional upper limit of the solid soluti on. This stabilizes the spinel in spite of positive enthalpy of disordering over the solid solution, where Delta H-D = alpha x + beta x(2), alpha = 22 (3), beta = -21(3) kJ mol(-1). This model for the cation distribution acros s the join suggests that the empirically determined limit of the spinel sol id solution is correlated with the limit of tetrahedral ordering of Mg, aft er which local charge-balanced substitution is no longer maintained. Spinelloid beta-Mg3Ga2GeO8 has cation distribution (M1)[Mg0.50(2)Ga0.50(2)] (M2)[Mg0.96(2)Ga0.04(2)] (M3)[Mg0.77(2)Ga0.23(2)](2) (Ge0.5Ga0.5)(2)O-8 (t etrahedral site occupancies are assumed). Octahedral site size is correlate d to ME distribution, where site volume. site distortion, and Mg content fo llow the relation M1 < M3 < M2. The disordered cation distribution provides local electrical neutrality in the structure, and stabilization through in creased configurational entropy (27.6 J mol(-1); eight oxygen basis). Compa rison of the crystal structures of Mg1+N Ga2-2NGeNO4 spinel, beta-Mg3Ga2GeO 8, and Mg2GeO4 olivine reveals beta-Mg3Ga2GeO8 to be a true structural inte rmediate. Phase transitions across the pseudobinary are necessary to accomm odate an increasing divergence of cation size and valence, with addition of Mg2GeO4 component. Octahedral volume increases while tetrahedral volume de creases from spinel to beta-Mg3Ga2GeO8 to olivine, with addition of Mg and Ge, respectively. Furthermore, M-M distances increase regularly across the join; suggesting that changes in topology reduce cation-cation repulsion.