The genus Rheumatobates comprises thirty-seven species and subspecies of Ne
w World water striders belonging to subfamily Rhagadotarsinae. Among specie
s, males vary dramatically in the degree and nature of modifications of the
antennae, three pairs of legs and abdominal and genital segments. Characte
rs describing this modification have traditionally been used to differentia
te and group species. The general assumption has been that modified species
belong to one group and unmodified species to another. These two 'species
groups' are subdivided into 'subgroups', but little effort has been made to
resolve relationships among them. We conduct the first numerical cladistic
analysis of Rheumatobates using a data set comprised of 102 characters, pr
imarily describing modification of male external morphology. To address con
cerns about the inclusion of characters to be optimized on the phylogeny, c
haracters describing modification of antennae and hind legs were included a
nd then excluded in separate analyses. A preferred phylogeny was chosen fro
m the four equally parsimonious cladograms found after successive reweighti
ng of characters. There was good resolution at all levels of the phylogeny.
Most of the major clades and terminal relationships were moderately to str
ongly supported, whereas the basal relationships were less well supported.
The general assumption that unmodified and modified species form two monoph
yletic groups was not supported. However, traditionally recognized 'subgrou
ps' within the modified species group were largely upheld. The analysis als
o suggested several major clades and relationships among these clades that
were not previously recognized. The exclusion of characters describing modi
fication of antennae and hind legs did not change the resolved major clades
of the reconstructed phylogeny.