General population survey data are used to disaggregate the associations of
substance use disorders with suicide attempts in order to evaluate a numbe
r of hypotheses about the processes leading to these associations. Data are
from the US National Comorbidity Survey (1990-1992). Discrete-time surviva
l analysis is used to study the effects of retrospectively reported tempora
lly prior substance use, abuse, and dependence in predicting first onset of
suicidal behavior. Alcohol and drug use predict subsequent suicide attempt
s after controlling for sociodemographics and comorbid mental disorders. Pr
evious use is not a significant predictor among current nonusers. Abuse and
dependence are significant predictors among users for three of the 10 subs
tances considered (alcohol, inhalants, and heroin). The number of substance
s used is more important than the types of substances used in predicting su
icidal behavior. Disaggregation shows that the effects of use are largely o
n suicidal ideation and nonplanned attempts among ideators. In comparison,
the effects of use on suicide plans and planned attempts among ideators are
not significant. Clinicians need to be aware that current substance use, e
ven in the absence of abuse or dependence, is a significant risk factor for
unplanned suicide attempts among ideators.