Cells can achieve error-free repair of DNA double-strand breaks (DSBs) by h
omologous recombination through gene conversion with or without crossover.
In contrast, an alternative homology-dependent DSB repair pathway, single-s
trand annealing (SSA), results in deletions. In this study, we analyzed the
effect of mRAD54, a gene involved in homologous recombination, on the repa
ir of a site-specific I-SceI-induced DSB located in a repeated DNA sequence
in the genome of mouse embryonic stem cells. We used six isogenic cell lin
es differing solely in the orientation of the repeats. The combination of t
he three recombination-test substrates used discriminated among SSA, intrac
hromatid gene conversion, and sister chromatid gene conversion. DSB repair
was most efficient for the substrate that allowed recovery of SSA events. G
ene conversion with crossover, indistinguishable from long tract gene conve
rsion, preferentially involved the sister chromatid rather than the repeat
on the same chromatid. Comparing DSB repair in mRAD54 wild-type and knockou
t cells revealed direct evidence for a role of mRAD54 in DSB repair. The su
bstrate measuring SSA showed an increased efficiency of DSB repair in the a
bsence of mRAD54. The substrate measuring sister chromatid gene conversion
showed a decrease in gene conversion with and without crossover. Consistent
with this observation, DNA damage-induced sister chromatid exchange was re
duced in mRAD54-deficient cells. Our results suggest that mRAD54 promotes g
ene conversion with predominant use of the sister chromatid as the repair t
emplate at the expense of error-prone SSA.