F. Vorbeck et al., Intraoperative computer aided navigation in ENT sinus surgery using Philips "NEUROGUIDE" system, RADIOLOGE, 40(3), 2000, pp. 227-232
Objective: To investigate the feasibility, precision and usefulness of comp
uter aided surgery in ENT-sinus surgery.
Material and Methods: 5 Patients with chronic sinus pathology and an indica
tion for sinus surgery were elected. For intraoperative navigation we used
a Philips "NEUROGUIDE" system and surgical instruments with LED's. Navigati
on procedures are described in detail in the paper, the system's precision
was measured by pointing at anatomical landmarks. The accuracy was measured
as the distance in millimeter between the bony structures of the CT scan o
n screen and the haircross of the pointer's tip on the screen. Another para
meter of the systems accuracy was calculated by the system itself as the ro
ot mean square error in millimeter (RMSE) between the registered markers po
sition and the marker position in the CT data set.
Results: Axial 3/3/1 mm spiral CT provided sufficient resolution, data tran
sfer via optical disk was practicable. Positioning of the navigation equipm
ent required some experience and the registration of the patients head posi
tion needed attention,as the markers have to be pointed at precisely. Durin
g operation, the head tracking system must not change its position on the p
atients head to ensure a correct navigation display. The main advantage of
the computed navigation system was the constant orientation during the sinu
s surgical procedure,frontiers and critical anatomical structures could be
identified in the corresponding CT data set,thus enabling the surgeon to de
cide on the further procedure. At present stage,the operation time was incr
eased through the handling of the navigation system for at about 15 min, re
sulting in additional time of narcosis.
Conclusion: We found the computed navigation system Philips "NEUROGUIDE" sy
stem to be an established technical aid, ready to use far ENT sinus surgery
, in our cases with a precision between 1 and 3 mm. These results were simi
lar to results obtained with a SPOCS Navigation System from Aesculap, as pr
eviously published by us [17].