In this essay, I reflect on the challenges faced by professors teaching Jew
ish studies in a Catholic university system. The essay records my experienc
es teaching two courses, "Judaism and the Holocaust" and "American Judaism:
Thought and Culture", at Santa Clara University as an adjunct lecturer dur
ing the academic year 1994-95. The essay touches on broader questions conce
rning "the dialectics of difference" that inform cross-cultural education a
nd exchange. Teaching Jewish studies in any gentile space (Catholic, Protes
tant, or secular) entails a constructive tension between trust and suspicio
n, candor and reserve.