Am. Neiman, Religious belief and education for spirituality after the Enlightenment: The vision of Elmer Thiessen, RELIG EDUC, 94(4), 1999, pp. 428-441
The ethos of the Enlightenment placed religious and spiritual concerns in a
private sphere, while politics became a public concern. In this vein, many
American educators, including John Dewey, have vigorously insisted that pu
blic schools remain free from religion while inculcating a common civic vir
tue. Recently, however, educational theorists and practitioners influenced
by Dewey have worried about the public's lack of spiritual intelligence and
have asked how democracy and spirituality might be reconciled within schoo
ls. I approach this question through an examination of Elmer Thiessen's "Te
aching for Commitment: Liberal Education, Indoctrination, and Christian Nur
ture" (1993). While not a follower of Dewey, Thiessen's work raises importa
nt questions for those who follow Dewey and who are concerned with the rela
tionship between democracy and spirituality.