Some states have recommended changing the definition of hat and elongated a
ggregates from 5:1 to 3:1 and an increase in the maximum allowable percenta
ge of flat and elongated (F&E) particles to 20% or higher in the Superpave
aggregate specification. Engineering justification and performance data are
required to rationally establish the criteria for this change. The objecti
ves of this research included the statistical analysis of performance indic
ators of Superpave mixtures containing different levels of 3: 1 particles.
Three mixes were designed and tested using 0, 15, and 40% of 3:1 particles
from a set of Kentucky limestone aggregates. This paper contains the findin
gs, conclusions, and recommendations on the research. The mixtures did not
differ significantly in their performance-related properties at lower and h
igher temperatures. However, at intermediate temperatures, significant diff
erences were observed. A curve shifting analysis confirmed the presence of
lower shear stiffness with an increase in the percentage of 3:1 F&E particl
es. The mix densification trends were inconclusive. Additionally, at low te
mperatures, the mixes with increasing percentages of 3:1 F&E particles seem
ed to have higher tensile strengths. This particular finding needs to be Fu
rther investigated. Overall, increases up to 40% of 3:1 F&E particles did n
ot adversely affect the performance potential of such mixes as measured by
the Superpave methodology.