R. Vogt et B. Vogt, GOLDHAGEN AND THE GERMANS - PSYCHOANALYTI C REFLECTIONS ON THE GERMANRESPONSE TO A BOOK AND ITS AUTHOR, Psyche, 51(6), 1997, pp. 494-569
Goldhagen proceeds on the hypothesis that the extermination of the Jew
s during the Third Reich was the product of a long history of anti-Sem
itism in Germany. The authors analyze this contention at three differe
nt levels, a) the individual (micro), b) the institutional (meso), and
c) the level of German society as a whole (macro). The (partly justif
ied) criticisms of Goldhagen's findings are interpreted by Vogt and Vo
gt as defense mechanisms (transformation into the opposite, projection
, denial, rationalization, derealization) largely motivated by a colle
ctive, unconscious, vicarious feeling of guilt. Together with genuine
insights, this collective vicarious feeling of guilt is also seen as t
he reason for Goldhagen's immense personal success in Germany, in chat
it favors idealizations (unconscious hopes of redemption, positive id
entifications) invested in the person of the author.