Does United States antidiscrimination law embrace a black/white binary para
digm of race, in which other, nonblack minority groups must compare their t
reatment to that of African Americans in order to gain redress? In this Der
rick Bell Lecture, Professor Richard Delgado argues that it does, and that
other minorities also fall from time to time into the trap of exceptionalis
m, placing their own experiences at the center of discussion. Taking as his
text a recent chronicle by Derrick Bell, Bluebeard's Castle, Professor Del
gado argues that narrow binary thinking-regardless of the group that engage
s in it-weakens solidarity, reduces opportunities for coalition, deprives o
ne group of the benefits of the others' experiences, makes one overly depen
dent on the approval of the white establishment, and sets one up for ultima
te disappointment. The black/white binary, in short, is bad for blacks, jus
t as her foolish fixation on the gloomy noble of operatic fame finally doom
ed Judith, the heroine of Bluebeard's Castle.