We report on a study of a model bioadhesion system: giant vesicles in conta
ct with a supported lipid bilayer. Embedded in both membranes are very low
concentrations of hemophilic recognition molecules (contact site A receptor
s) competing with higher concentrations of repeller molecules: polyethylene
glycol (PEG) lipids. These repellers mimic the inhibiting effect of the ce
ll glycocalyx on adhesion. The effective adhesive interaction between the t
wo membranes is probed by interferometric analysis of thermal fluctuations.
We find two competing states of adhesion: initial weak adhesion is followe
d by slower aggregation of the adhesion molecules into small, tightly bound
clusters that coexist with the regions of weak adhesion. We interpret our
results in terms of a double-well intermembrane potential, and we present a
theoretical analysis of the intermembrane interaction in the presence of m
obile repeller molecules at a fixed chemical potential that shows that the
interaction potential indeed should have just such a double-well shape. At
a fixed repeller concentration we recover a conventional purely repulsive p
otential. We discuss the implications of our findings in terms of a general
amplification mechanism of the action of sparse adhesion molecules by a no
nspecific double-well potential. We also discuss the important role of the
Helfrich undulation force for the proposed scenario.