N. Press et al., Collective fear, individualized risk: The social and cultural context of genetic testing for breast cancer, NURS ETHICS, 7(3), 2000, pp. 237-249
The purpose of this article is to provide a critical examination of two asp
ects of culture and biomedicine that have helped to shape the meaning and p
ractice of genetic testing for breast cancer. These are: (1) the cultural c
onstruction of fear of breast cancer, which has been fuelled in part by (2)
the predominance of a 'risk' paradigm in contemporary biomedicine, The inc
reasing elaboration and delineation of risk factors and risk numbers are in
part intended to help women to contend with their fear of breast cancer. H
owever, because there is no known cure or foolproof prevention for breast c
ancer, risk designations bring with them recommendations for vigilant surve
illance strategies and screening guidelines. We argue that these in effect
exacerbate women's fears of breast cancer itself. The volatile combination
of discourses of fear, risk and surveillance have significant ethical and s
ocial consequences for women's lives and well-being. Genetic testing decisi
ons are made within this context; if nurses understand this context they ca
n play an important role in helping women to cope with the anxiety and fear
of breast cancer risk.