We tested evolution-based hypotheses about (1) sex differences in perceived
benefits and costs of opposite-sex friendship and (2) differences in perce
ived benefits of same-sex friendships and opposite-sex friendships. In the
Preliminary Study (N = 400), an act nomination procedure was used to identi
fy the benefits and costs of same-sex friendships and opposite-sex friendsh
ips. In Study 1, a total of 231 participants (100 men, 132 women) evaluated
the frequency of occurrence of 100 benefits and costs in their closest sam
e-sex friendship or opposite-sex friendship. In Study 2, a total of 229 par
ticipants (92 men, 137 women) evaluated how beneficial and how costly each
would be if it were to occur in their closest same-sex friendship or opposi
te-sex friendship. Results supported several key hypotheses. Men perceived
sex with their opposite-sex friends as more beneficial than did women. Wome
n reported receiving protection from their opposite-sex friends more often
than did men, and they perceived the protection as highly beneficial. Both
men and women reported receiving information from opposite-sex friends abou
t how to attract mates, and they perceived this information as beneficial.
The discussion focuses on whether these benefits reflect an evolved psychol
ogy of opposite-sex friendship, or instead are incidental by-products.