C. Byrne et al., Health education or empowerment education with individuals with a serious persistent psychiatric disability, PSYCH REH J, 22(4), 1999, pp. 368-380
This study tested the effectiveness of health education versus empowerment
education with individuals with a chronic and persistent mental illness. A
randomized, controlled trial design was used in 22 community group homes. T
he Lehman Quality of Life Scale was administered prior to the interventions
, immediately following the intervention, and then 6 months later. Health s
ervices utilization was also measured. Although Quality of Life scores impr
oved over time, there were no statistically significant differences found b
etween groups in Quality of Life and use of health services. There were cli
nically important gains (20%) in global quality of life for a specific subs
et of individuals who endorsed a life low in satisfaction and with little h
ope for the future, and this also resulted in more expense for resource con
sumption. Results of this study highlight issues of the length of time to p
roduce changes in individuals with a severe illness and the sensitivity of
quality-of-life measures in evaluating interventions.