A. Vieillard-baron et al., Predictors of mortality in acute respiratory distress syndrome - Focus on the role of right heart catheterization, AM J R CRIT, 161(5), 2000, pp. 1597-1601
Right heart catheterization (RHC) has been suspected of increasing mortalit
y. The acute respiratory distress syndrome (ARDS) is a frequent reason for
RHC. We designed a retrospective cohort study of 119 consecutive ARDS patie
nts admitted to two medical intensive care units of tertiary care hospitals
in which two different approaches are used for hemodynamic monitoring: RHC
on demand (Henri Mondor Hospital [HM]) and no use of RHC (Ambroise Pare Ho
spital [AP]). The study tried to identify risk factors for death, and to as
sess the influence of RHC, with adjustment for the intensity of hemodynamic
support as a confounding factor, using 98 patients in whom the delay betwe
en onset of ARDS, use of vasopressors, and RHC did not exceed 48 h. Several
variables, including septic shock, cause of ARDS, Simplified Acute Physiol
ogy Score (SAPS) II, use of epinephrine/norepinephrine, and presence of RHC
were entered into a logistic regression model to evaluate their independen
t prognostic roles. Mortality was different at HM and AP (36 of 55 patients
[65.5%] versus 16 of 43 patients [37.2%], p < 0.005), and 29 of the 35 RHC
-monitored patients died (82.8%), as compared with 23 of 63 patients (36.5%
) treated without RHC (p < 0.0001). However, administration of epinephrine/
norepinephrine and a nonpulmonary cause of ARDS were each independently ass
ociated with death. It is only when administration of vasopressors was omit
ted from the model that RHC, septic shock, and SAPS II became independent p
redictors of mortality. These results suggest that: (I) the use of vasopres
sors, but not of RHC, represents an important prognostic: factor; and (2) n
ot taking into account the use of these drugs may be misleading when assess
ing the influence of RHC on outcome.