Rc. Karl et al., Factors affecting morbidity, mortality, and survival in patients undergoing Ivor Lewis esophagogastrectomy, ANN SURG, 231(5), 2000, pp. 635-641
Objectives
To examine the safety of transthoracic esophagogastrectomy (TTE) in a multi
disciplinary cancer center and to determine which clinical parameters influ
enced survival and the rates of death and complications.
Summary Background Data
Although the incidence of cancer at the gastroesophageal junction has been
rising rapidly in the United States, controversy still exists about the saf
ety of surgical procedures designed to remove the distal esophagus and prox
imal stomach. Alternatives to TTE have been proposed because of the reporte
dly high rates of death and complications associated with the procedure.
Methods
Data from 143 patients treated by TTE by one author (1989-1999) were entere
d into a computerized database. Preoperative clinical parameters were teste
d for effect on death, complications, and survival.
Results The patient population consisted of 127 men and 16 women. One hundr
ed twenty-one patients had a history of tobacco abuse, and 118 reported the
regular ingestion of alcohol. One hundred fifteen patients had adenocarcin
oma, 16 had squamous cell cancer, 6 had another form of esophageal tumor, a
nd 6 had high-grade dysplasia associated with Barrett epithelia. Fifty-six
patients had adenocarcinomas arising in Barrett epithelium. Twenty-eight pa
tients were treated with neoadjuvant chemoradiation before surgery. Three p
atients died within 30 days of surgery (mortality rate 2.1%), Five patients
(3.5%) had a documented anastomotic leak; three died). Overall, 42 patient
s had complications (29%). Twenty-six had pulmonary complications (19%). Th
e mean length of stay in the intensive care unit was 3.35 days; the mean ho
spital length of stay was 13.54 days. The overall 3-year survival rate was
29,6%,
Conclusions
A high ASA score and the development of complications predicted an increase
d length of stay. The presence of diabetes predicted the development of com
plication and an increased length of stay. None of the other parameters tes
ted predicted perioperative death or complications. Only disease stage, dia
betes, and blood transfusion affected overall survival. From these results
with a large series of patients with gastroesophageal junction cancers, TTE
can be performed with a low death rate (2.1%), a low leak rate (3.5%), and
an acceptable complication rate (29%).