Objective To examine the role of clean intermittent catheterization (CIC) a
s a possible predisposing risk factor for bladder calculi, assessing risk f
actors in patients with and without bladder augmentation, and to evaluate m
anagement options for bladder calculi in these patients.
Patients and methods The records of 403 patients who were using a regimen o
f CIC between January 1981 and March 1998 were reviewed to identify those f
orming bladder calculi; stones were diagnosed in 28 patients. The patients
were categorized as: group 1, patients with no bladder augmentation who cat
heterized urethrally (227, group 1a) or via a Mitrofanoff conduit (18, grou
p 1b); group 2, patients with augmented bladders who catheterized urethrall
y (100, group 2a) or via a Mitrofanoff conduit (58, group 2b). The incidenc
e of bladder calculi in each group was determined and compared statisticall
y where applicable. The success of the treatment options for stone manageme
nt was reviewed.
Results Bladder calculi developed in 5% of patients in group 1a, 8% in grou
p 2a, 11% in group 1b, and 10% in group 2b; the incidence of calculi was no
t significantly different among the groups. Of these patients, 18 (64%) wer
e asymptomatic at the time of diagnosis and significant bacteriuria was fou
nd in 23 (88%). Difficulty in catheterizing either the Mitrofanoff conduit
or the native urethra was reported in 14 (50%) of these patients. Calculi w
ere more often solitary (71%) and typically composed of struvite or apatite
. Calculi were managed by open cystolithotomy in 15 patients (54%) and endo
scopically in 13 (46%). Stones recurred in nine patients (32%) after treatm
ent, comprising four of six patients treated endoscopically with electrohyd
raulic lithotripsy and in five of 15 after open cystolithotomy. The mean in
terval to recurrence was 22.8 months.
Conclusion These results suggest that patients on a regimen of CIC are at r
isk of developing bladder calculi but the incidence of calculi is not influ
enced by bladder augmentation. The presence of a Mitrofanoff conduit was as
sociated with a slightly increased incidence of calculus formation. Open cy
stolithotomy was associated with a lower stone recurrence rate but there we
re too few patients to draw definitive conclusions.