P. Santuz et al., EXERCISE PERFORMANCE IN CHILDREN WITH ASTHMA - IS IT DIFFERENT FROM THAT OF HEALTHY CONTROLS, The European respiratory journal, 10(6), 1997, pp. 1254-1260
Exercise tolerance and possible limitation in work capacity of asthmat
ic children is still a matter of debate. The aim of this study was to
compare ventilation and gas exchange response to exercise of asthmatic
children viith that of healthy control. Exercise performance was eval
uated in 80 children with mild-to-moderate asthma, aged 1-15 yrs, and
in 80 healthy controls matched for age, height, weight and habitual le
vel of physical activity, The children performed a maximal exercise te
st on a treadmill, during which oxygen uptake (V'O-2), carbon dioxide
output (V'CO2) and minute ventilation (V'E) were measured continuously
, No premedication was given to the asthmatic children. Forced expirat
ory volume in one second (FEV1) at rest was 93+/-11% of predicted in a
sthmatic children and 95+/-9% pred in controls, After the run, the mea
n fall in FEV1 was 13.9% (range 0-57%) and 1.6% (0-9%), respectively (
p<0.001). The two groups achieved similar maximum oxygen uptake (V'O-2
,max) ((mean+/-SD) 40.3+/- 8.4 and 42.6+/-9.6 mL.min(-1).kg(-1) in ast
hmatics and controls, respectively; Ns) and maximum minute ventilation
output (V'E,max) (42.9+/-14.5 and 45.7+/-14.9 L.min(-1) respectively;
NS). The kinetics of V'O-2, V'CO2 and V'E during the test revealed no
differences between the two populations, Moreover, anaerobic threshol
d and oxygen pulse were the same in the two groups. Asthmatics showed
a ventilatory pattern with lower respiratory frequencies and greater t
idal volumes during the run. These results suggest that asthmatic chil
dren can achieve a level of exercise performance similar to that of he
althy children, provided that they have a comparable level of habitual
physical activity. The only difference found concerned the ventilator
y pattern of the asthmatic children, which was characterized by a redu
ced respiratory frequency and greater tidal volume at the same minute
ventilation, The level of physical conditioning was found to be the ma
in determinant of exercise tolerance for children with controlled asth
ma.