All spatial urban models with congestion assume that the departure (arrival
) time of commutes is exogenously determined and assume that travel speed a
t a given time and location depends upon the traffic density at that point
in time and space. This paper presents a framework that encompasses such mo
dels, but allows workers to choose the time at which they leave home (arriv
e at work). This paper then proves that in general only one equilibrium exi
sts for urban models with traditional congestion technology: a commuting pa
ttern in which commuting is continuous and the rush hour never ends, which
is unrepresentative of traffic patterns anywhere. This paper concludes by d
iscussing alternative general equilibrium urban models with congestion that
may have more realistic equilibria. (C) 2000 Academic Press.