Populations of Datura wrightii vary in the frequency of plants that produce
glandular trichomes, a resistance trait under the control of a single gene
. Such variation may be maintained if the production of glandular trichomes
is costly in the absence of herbivory, and if selection imposed by herbivo
re communities varies spatially or temporally. Here, we document costs in t
he presence of herbivory for established glandular plants relative to estab
lished non-glandular plants growing in natural populations from coastal mou
ntain, Riversidian sage scrub, and Mojave desert habitats in southern Calif
ornia. Damage caused by the herbivore community varied spatially, with sign
ificant differences in herbivore-specific damage between plants of the two
trichome types and among populations within habitats, although not generall
y among habitats. Plants with greater canopy size and canopy persistence ha
d higher viable seed production than smaller or more damaged plants, but th
is relationship was statistically significant only for non-glandular plants
. However, the relationship between viable seed production and canopy persi
stence became significant for glandular plants when damage caused by sap su
ckers, which do not remove leaf area, was pooled with undamaged leaf area.
The high cost exhibited by glandular plants leads us to predict that in the
absence of any additional, unknown benefits of producing glandular trichom
es, the frequency of these plants should decline in all natural populations
of D. wrightii.