Leaf litter inhabiting beetles as surrogates for establishing priorities for conservation of selected tropical montane cloud forests in Honduras, Central America (Coleoptera; Staphylinidae, Curculionidae)
Rs. Anderson et Js. Ashe, Leaf litter inhabiting beetles as surrogates for establishing priorities for conservation of selected tropical montane cloud forests in Honduras, Central America (Coleoptera; Staphylinidae, Curculionidae), BIODIVERS C, 9(5), 2000, pp. 617-653
Thirteen tropical montane cloud forests (TMCFs) in Honduras and adjacent El
Salvador were evaluated for species diversity and endemism in leaf litter
inhabiting Curculionidae (weevils) and Staphylinidae in June and August of
1994. Totals of 26,891 specimens representing 293 species of Curculionidae,
and 7349 specimens representing 224 species of Staphylinidae, were collect
ed. Regional endemism was high with 173 species (58.7% of total) of Curculi
onidae and 126 species (56.3% of total) of Staphylinidae, restricted to sin
gle sites. Measures of diversity (number of observed species [Sobs]; number
of endemic species) and estimates of biodiversity (Chao 2, first and secon
d order Jackknife and Bootstrap richness estimators) are given for each sit
e for Curculionidae and Staphylinidae. Priority-areas analyses based on Sob
s ('Greedy'), Sobs, Chao 2, number of endemic species, site complementarity
and higher taxonomic diversity (Curculionidae only) are presented. Weak or
lack of correlation was noted between site area and site diversity for eit
her Curculionidae or Staphylinidae. The optimum sequence for site conservat
ion was determined based on Sobs ('Greedy'). Four sites are identified as t
he highest conservation priorities; Parque Nacional Montecristo, P.N. La Mu
ralla, P.N. Santa Barbara and P.N. Comayagua. Identification as high priori
ty sites supports their designation as Parques Nacionales rather than the l
ess diverse Reservas Biologias or Reservas Vidas Silvestres. While closely
approximating performance of Sobs ('Greedy'), no one of Sobs, number of end
emics, Chao 2 or site complementarity give results equivalent to the optimu
m sequence based on Sobs ('Greedy') and the latter is concluded to be the b
est method for establishing conservation priorities in TMCF. Results of the
analyses based on one of Curculionidae or Staphylinidae differ in the orde
ring of site priorities based on each of Sobs, Chao 2 or number of endemics
at each site, with at best, weak positive correlations between results bas
ed on each taxon. Data from other taxa are necessary to determine if one of
Curculionidae or Staphylinidae emerges as the better surrogate for general
patterns of biodiversity in TMCF. Conservation strategies in Central Ameri
ca should emphasize the importance of TMCF particularly in view of high reg
ional endemism. In formulating these strategies, consideration needs to be
given to the preservation of many small regional preserves rather than fewe
r larger preserves. Data from inventories of other taxa should be included
where available and all biological data should be integrated with social an
d cultural issues of regional importance.