The development of a medial crossover second toe (second toe crossing over
the first toe) is not a rare clinical condition. It often occurs in the set
ting of hallux valgus, although not exclusively so. The resulting displacem
ent of the second toe can cause pain in shoes, with surgical correction bei
ng problematic. The pathologic anatomy of this condition has not been fully
described. In an effort to better understand it, dissection of a cadaveric
specimen with a full crossover toe is presented. The dissection revealed f
indings not previously documented. They include medial displacement of the
flexor tendons and plantar plate along with deformity of the plate itself.
These changes are in addition to contracture of the medial collateral ligam
ents and the previously described rupture of the lateral collateral ligamen
ts. Both the plantar plate and the collateral ligaments, the two major stat
ic soft tissue stabilizers of the lesser MP joint, were found to be signifi
cantly involved. Pull on the flexor tendons only accentuated the malalignme
nt of the toe.
Clinical Significance: The extensive soft tissue changes explain the diffic
ulty in achieving a successful long term correction of a full medial crosso
ver toe with a soft tissue procedure. With attenuation of the plantar plate
and medial displacement of the flexor tendons, there is an imbalance of mu
scle forces across the MP joint. This muscle imbalance would not be correct
ed by release of the medial collateral ligament, dorsal capsular release or
extensor tendon lengthening. Reconstruction of the collateral ligament is
at risk for incomplete correction since it is unlikely to resolve deformity
in the plate if already present.