It is well known that when all voters in an electorate have preferences con
sistent with a single underlying dimension, then the electorate's aggregate
preferences must be transitive However, analyses of historical elections s
uggest that voters frequently view political alternatives (parties and cand
idates) arrayed along not one, but two principal dimensions. Building on ea
rlier work by Feld and Grofman, we develop a simple geometric method to rep
resent necessary and sufficient conditions for transitive majority decision
s in two-dimensional policy space. This method provides an intuition as to
why transitivity in the two-dimensional case is virtually guaranteed, given
realistic positioning by parties and candidates. We illustrate and support
our conclusions by analyzing data on the spatial distributions of voters a
nd parties in recent French and British elections.