Wittite and cannizzarite, two rare and structurally related nonstoichiometr
ic sulfosalts belonging to the system Pb-Bi-S-Se, were found together aroun
d high-temperature fumaroles at La Fossa crater, Vulcano island, Italy. Thi
s occurrence makes a comparative study by different methods possible (scann
ing electron microscope, electron microprobe, and X-ray and electron diffra
ction). Ne discuss once more the question whether or not they are distinct
mineral species. Cannizzarite was found in samples collected from 1990 to 1
995 in assemblages with bismuthinite and galenobismutite (mostly), in some
cases with lillianite, heyrovskiite, Se-bearing galena, kirkiite, and the n
ew species mozgovaite. Wittite was revealed only in samples collected in 19
95 around the fumarole vent F11 in association with bismuthinite. Both mine
rals form aggregates of very tiny sheaves of slightly divergent, bladed cry
stals (cannizzarite up to 0.5 mm in length and 0.07 mm in width; wittite up
to 2 mm in length). The electron-microprobe data obtained (141 analyses) s
how significant variations in proportions of the main elements. In terms of
Bi/(Bi + Pb), the range of composition is 3.14 at.%; the Se content varies
from less than 1 to 14.65 wt%. The composition field of the minerals under
consideration may be described by the general empirical chemical formula P
b3+xBi4-x(S9-ySe (y))(9-x/2) or Pb-3(Bi4-xPbx)(4) (S9-ySey)(9-x/2), with 0.
04 less than or equal to x less than or equal to 0.28, and 0.5 less than or
equal to y less than or equal to 3.5. Electron-diffraction data and X-ray
investigations of a sample of wittite containing similar to 8.5 wt% Se conf
irm that cannizzarite and wittite have the same structure. Measured unit-ce
ll parameters show that volumes of the Il and Q subcells both Vary in direc
t proportion to Se content. No chemical discontinuity between cannizzarite
and wittite series has been observed up to 40 at.% Se; consequently, wittit
e may be validated or discredited as a distinct mineral species only when a
definitive crystallographic work will prove that Se exceeds S in the H lay
ers.