Sa. Newton et al., Headshaking in horses: possible aetiopathogenesis suggested by the resultsof diagnostic tests and several treatment regimes used in 20 cases, EQUINE V J, 32(3), 2000, pp. 208-216
Twenty mature horses with typical headshaking of 2 week-7 year duration wer
e studied. Clinical examinations included radiography of the head and nasop
haryngeal endoscopy. All were assessed at rest and at exercise, both before
and after fitting an occlusive nasal mask, application of tinted contact l
enses and the perineural anaesthesia of the infraorbital and posterior ethm
oidal branches of the trigeminal nerve. Infraorbital anaesthesia had no eff
ect in 6/7 cases but 11/17 (65%) cases showed a 90-100% improvement followi
ng posterior ethmoidal nerve anaesthesia. Tinted contact lenses had no appa
rent long-term benefit, although 2 cases showed a transient improvement. We
found no other evidence to suggest a photic aetiology in the current serie
s of cases. Treatment regimens based on the results of the diagnostic inves
tigative methods included sclerosis of the posterior ethmoidal branch of th
e trigeminal nerve. This was effective in some cases but the benefits were
temporary. Cyproheptadine alone was ineffective but the addition of carbama
zepine resulted in 80-100% improvement in 80% of cases. Carbemazepine alone
was effective in 88% of cases but results were unpredictable at predefined
dose rates. The positive response to carbamazepine, combined with the clin
ical features is consistent with involvement of the trigeminal nerve, parti
cularly the more proximal branches such as the posterior ethmoidal nerve.
Headshaking has some clinical features in common with trigeminal neuralgia
in humans. As a result of the findings detailed in this paper, we conclude
that a trigeminal neuritis or neuralgia may be the basis of the underlying
aetiopathology of equine headshaking. Initial observations of the positive
response of headshakers to carbamazepine therapy is encouraging. However, f
uture studies will include a more detailed investigation of dosages, durati
on of effectiveness (in some cases it appears short-lived) and other effect
s. In practice there is a realistic possibility of controlling but not curi
ng headshaking with carbamazepine therapy at the present time. Other future
investigations will include details of the functional anatomy of the trige
minal nerve and the role of the P2 myelin protein in headshaking and other
neurological disease.