Rh. Riffenburgh et al., ASSOCIATION OF SCHISTOSOMIASIS WITH CERVICAL-CANCER - DETECTING BIAS IN CLINICAL-STUDIES, East African medical journal, 74(1), 1997, pp. 14-16
To investigate if Schistosoma haematobium infection increases the obse
rved frequency of cervical cancer, data from literature were analysed
in meta-analysis fashion, Results reveal that cervical cancer is stati
stically significantly less frequent in the presence of S. haematobium
infection. A protective effect might be inferred; however, underlying
bias in data collection and/or analysis is suspected, An approach to
detecting bias is given, consisting of: (a) carefully stating and asse
ssing the several components of the scientific method and; (b) identif
ying and contrasting the populations hypothesised and sampled, The app
roach is illustrated by searching for bias in the schistosomiasis-and-
cancer reports. Sampling discrepancies were detected in patient geogra
phy, ages, and states of health, and suspected in disease prevalence s
ampled and disease prevalence reported, The conclusion is reached that
effects of bias in the original studies preclude inference of a ''pro
tective'' effect of S. haematobium infection against cervical cancer.