We estimate the impact of taxes on donations using a large panel of mi
ddle-class taxpayers. Our specification allows estimation of the effec
ts of habits, time shifting, and consumption smoothing on the time pat
h of adjustment and produces plausible simulated adjustment paths to p
ermanent and temporary anticipated tax reforms. We find that taxes det
ermine both the long-run level and the timing of donations, so that, e
ven though taxes appear to have long-run behavioral effects, estimates
of these effects are exaggerated if one fails to estimate the resched
uling of giving in response to tax regime shifts. Our results challeng
e the view that tax deductions for charitable giving are efficient.