Dc. Lee et An. Halliday, Accretion of primitive planetesimals: Hf-W isotopic evidence from enstatite chondrites, SCIENCE, 288(5471), 2000, pp. 1629-1631
Enstatite chondrites have often been considered to be closely related to th
e material from which Earth accreted. However, tungsten isotopic data revea
l clear differences. Moreover, the silicate and metal fractions define dist
inct initial H-182/Hf-180 corresponding to a 13.8 +/- 5.3 million year appa
rent age difference. Internal reequilibration does not provide a ready expl
anation for this result. Larger scale redistribution of tungsten is more li
kely, such as may have occurred during collisions between planetesimals.