B. Stengel et al., Age, blood pressure and smoking effects on chronic renal failure in primary glomerular nephropathies, KIDNEY INT, 57(6), 2000, pp. 2519-2526
Background. Smoking is a known risk factor for renal damage in diabetic pat
ients, but its relationship to other renal diseases is less clear. To asses
s its effect in primary glomerular nephropathy (GN), we used data from a ca
se control study designed to assess several environmental risk factors.
Methods. This study included 295 biopsy-proven GN cases, 80 membranous neph
ropathy, 116 IgA nephropathy, and 99 nephrotic syndrome with either minimal
change nephropathy or focal segmental hyalinosis, and 242 matched hospital
controls, with diseases unrelated to smoking. Subjects were interviewed ab
out their smoking history. Chronic renal failure (CRF), defined by serum cr
eatinine >150 mu mol/L, was present in 74 cases (57 men and 17 women). Logi
stic regression was used to estimate odds ratios (ORs) adjusted for age and
social class.
Results. In men, the percentage of ever-smokers did not differ between GN c
ases (60%) and controls [65%, OR = 0.9 (95% Confidence Interval 0.6-1.4)],b
ut was significantly higher among cases with CRF (75%) than those without [
55%, OR = 2.4 (1.24.5)]. Dose-effect relationships were observed with both
the daily and cumulative dose; this relationship was stronger in the compar
ison of cases with CRF and those without CRF than in the comparison of case
s with CRF with controls: OR = 1.9 versus 1.3 (less than or equal to 20 cig
arettes/day) and OR = 5.2 versus 3.0 (>20 cigarettes/day); OR = 1.9 versus
1.4 (less than or equal to 15 pack years) and OR = 3.9 vs. 2.0 (>15 pack ye
ars). Interactions between age, hypertension, and smoking were observed in
the risk of CRF: smoking was significantly related to CRF among cases who w
ere older than 40 years and/or hypertensive, but not among those cases youn
ger than 40 or normotensive. The results did not significantly differ among
the three histologic types. No relationship was shown between smoking and
CRF in women.
Conclusion. This study provides additional support for the hypothesis that
smoking is related to GN severity, particularly in the at-risk groups of me
n older than 40 and/or hypertensive patients. These findings should be corr
oborated by further observations in other populations.