Seed size and shape predict seed persistence in the soil for British and Ar
gentinian herbaceous plant species. Those species with small, rounded seeds
tend to have persistent seeds while those with larger, more elongate or fl
attened seeds usually lack persistence. It has been suggested that the mech
anism underlying this pattern maybe ease of burial, as small, rounded seeds
are incorporated into the soil more easily than large, elongate or flatten
ed seeds and are therefore less likely to be eaten by seed predators. We te
sted whether seed size and shape were related to persistence in the soil fo
r 47 species native to New Zealand forests. There was a tendency for specie
s with persistent seeds to have smaller seeds than species with transient s
eeds. However, species with large and/or elongate or flattened persistent s
eeds were relatively common. This indicates that seed size and shape are no
t related to persistence in New Zealand in the same way as in Britain and A
rgentina. A similar negative result has been found in Australia. The underl
ying cause of the patterns observed is unlikely to be ease of burial, since
incorporation of seeds into the soil is likely to operate in all countries
in a similar manner on seeds without specialised seed burial mechanisms. D
ata from all four floras studied to date also suggest that species with sma
ll, rounded seeds that do not germinate immediately must have the ability t
o survive periods of burial.