Multiculturalism and truthfulness: Negotiating differences by finding similarities

Our cultural disagreements can often be anticipated, negotiated and resolve d using shared methods of moral reasoning. This claim is incompatible with any extreme version of communitarianism or strong ethical relativism, which hold that one's culture is the final arbiter of good, bad, right and wrong , or that the rights of the community should trump individual rights within that community. This view is discussed and found to be implausible using t he example of common grounds for responding to different cultural views abo ut being truthful in medical practice. Its implausibility stems from diffic ulties individuating cultures, and accounting for intercultural goals, valu es and methods. Given our increasingly diverse populations, problems arise as clinicians from one culture try to care respectfully and compassionately for people from other groups. Yet working from shared values and goals, we can use some bridging methods such as discussing grim news in the third pe rson. Claims that something is a cultural belief or attitude, moreover, can not always be taken at face value. Various meanings of 'multiculturalism' a re distinguished.