Nutrient enrichment of marine sediments or the water column has been used t
o study plant nutrient limitation and its cascading effects on community st
ructure. Here we develop methodological recommendations for in situ enrichm
ent. We review 18 published enrichment methods. Nutrient concentrations var
ied through time and among sites, with sediment depth, distance from the so
urce, fertilizer type and load. Combining available data, we could predict
an increase in sediment porewater phosphate (r(2) = 0.48) but not ammonium
(r(2) = 0.07) concentrations in a multiple regression model. In three compa
rative field experiments we applied a coated slow-release fertilizer in the
sediment and the water column and followed nutrient concentrations over ti
me. We recommend coated fertilizer pellets; because they provide gradual nu
trient release, allow for realistic nutrient gradients, and even applicatio
n but we emphasize that nutrient concentrations need to be monitored throug
h time.