Background: Accumulating evidence indicates decreased melatonin levels in p
atients with schizophrenia. Insomnia, mainly difficulty in falling asleep a
t night, is commonly reported in this population. Association of insomnia w
ith low or abnormal melatonin rhythms has been repeatedly documented. Melat
onin is an endogenous sleep promoter in humans. We hypothesized that insomn
ia in patients with schizophrenia may be partially due to diminished melato
nin output. In this study, we measured melatonin output in patients with ch
ronic schizophrenia and assessed the effects of melatonin replacement on th
eir sleep quality.
Method: In a randomized, double-blind, crossover, clinically based trial, 1
9 patients with DSM-IV schizophrenia who were treated with the normal treat
ment regimen were given melatonin (2 mg, controlled release) or placebo for
2 treatment periods of 3 weeks each with 1 week washout between treatment
periods (7 weeks total). For measuring endogenous melatonin production, uri
ne was collected from each patient every 3 hours between 9:00 p.m. and 9:00
a.m. Actigraphy was performed for 3 consecutive nights at the end of each
period. Activity- and rest-derived sleep parameters were compared for the w
hole population with treatment arm as the intervening variable. A separate
analysis was performed for patients subgrouped into high versus low sleep e
fficiency.
Results: All patients had low melatonin output. Melatonin replacement signi
ficantly improved rest-derived sleep efficiency compared with placebo (83.5
% vs. 78.2%, p = .038) in this population. Improvement of sleep efficiency
was significantly greater (p < .0014) in low-efficiency (80% vs. 67%) than
high-efficiency sleepers (88% vs. 90%). In addition, during melatonin thera
py, tendencies toward shortened sleep latency (by 40 minutes, p < .056) and
increased sleep duration (by 45 minutes, p < .078) were observed in low- b
ut not high-efficiency sleepers.
Conclusion: Melatonin improves sleep efficiency in patients with schizophre
nia whose sleep quality is low.