Functional MR imaging of the craniocervical junction. correlation with alar ligaments and occipito-atlantoaxial joint morphology: a study in 50 asymptomatic subjects
Cwa. Pfirrmann et al., Functional MR imaging of the craniocervical junction. correlation with alar ligaments and occipito-atlantoaxial joint morphology: a study in 50 asymptomatic subjects, SCHW MED WO, 130(18), 2000, pp. 645-651
Purpose: Whiplash injuries are frequent in industrialised countries. The ac
ute and chronic symptoms following such injuries are incompletely understoo
d and objective clinical or imaging findings are rare. Several authors have
suspected that rear end collisions occurring when the head is rotated may
result in tears of the alar ligaments. There has been experimental proof th
at a torn alar ligament increases the rotation of the C0/C1 and C1/C2 segme
nts to the contralateral side. Functional cross sectional imaging has there
fore been proposed to diagnose injuries of the alar ligaments. So far, publ
ished data on normal ranges of rotation in an asymptomatic population have
been sparse. The aim of this study was to determine by MR imaging the norma
l range of rotation in the first three cervical segments and their relation
to the morphology of the alar ligaments and the occipito-atlantoaxial join
ts.
Material and methods: Functional MR imaging of the craniocervical junction
in maximum active left and right head rotation was performed in 50 healthy
volunteers with a mean age of 29.8 years (31 men, 19 women, range 19-47 yea
rs). Measurements were independently performed by two musculoskeletal radio
logists to assess interobserver error. The results were correlated with gen
der and age, with morphological findings in the occipito-atlantoaxial joint
s (i.e. joint symmetry, joint effusions, dens position), and with the form,
course and symmetry of the alar ligaments.
Results: The mean range of rotation for the C0/C1 joint was 2.7 degrees (st
andard deviation [SD] 3.3 degrees) /3.3 degrees (SD 3.6 degrees) (right/lef
t) and at the C1/C2 level 38 degrees (SD 6.5 degrees) /37.8 degrees (SD 6.4
degrees). The mean differences in left/right rotation were: C0/C1 3.5 degr
ees (SD 2.8 degrees) and C1/C2 6.3 degrees (SD 4.4 degrees). No correlation
was found between segmental rotation and morphological characteristics of
the craniocervical joints or ligament structures.
Conclusion: There is wide variation of segmental motion in the upper cervic
al spine. Differences in right-to-left rotation are frequently encountered
in an asymptomatic population. Therefore, these measurements are unsuitable
for indirect diagnosis of soft tissue lesions after whiplash injury and sh
ould not be used as a basis for treatment guidelines.